- The Empire Club of Canada Addresses (Toronto, Canada), 4 Jun 1998, p. 50-61
- McLellan, The Hon. Anne, Speaker
- Media Type
- Item Type
- A joint meeting of The Empire Club of Canada and The Canadian Club of Toronto.
The speaker's perspective on issues as a representative of the government and the cabinet from Western Canada. A brief reflection on the country's expanding power base, on the fact that the West is assuming an increasingly important economic role in Canada's federation, and what that means for the governance of Canada and our choices. Some of the speaker's challenges as Minister of Justice in respect to some of these challenges. Comments on the national economy. Canadians feeling optimistic again. How Canada got to its current economic situation. The economy of the West of Canada, and how it has outpaced the rest of the country. Some economic facts and figures. The West, not just growing but diversifying, with illustration. Indicators of the West's growing strength. Population moving westward. Evidence of a gradual economic realignment. The West's demand for greater influence in the country's affairs. The Reform Party as one manifestation of this; the speaker's argument that it is an unfortunate one, and why. Examples of the West's strong influence. Some misconceptions about the West and Westerners. Comments on Canada's criminal justice system. Profound changes in Canadian society over the past 30 years. Results of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Our justice system, slow to respond to these new realities and pressures. The position of Aboriginal peoples in their dealings with the justice system. The need to change the way our justice system operates, with illustration and suggestions for change. A new direction for justice in Canada, announced this week in the National Strategy on Community Safety and Crime Prevention. What that Strategy recognizes about Canadians. Overcoming regional differences and working in partnership. A bright new millennium for Canada.
- Date of Original
- 4 Jun 1998
- Language of Item
- Copyright Statement
- The speeches are free of charge but please note that the Empire Club of Canada retains copyright. Neither the speeches themselves nor any part of their content may be used for any purpose other than personal interest or research without the explicit permission of the Empire Club of Canada.
- Empire Club of CanadaEmail
Agency street/mail address
Fairmont Royal York Hotel
100 Front Street West, Floor H
Toronto, ON, M5J 1E3
- Full Text
- The Hon. Anne McLellan, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada
A VIEW FROM THE WEST
Chairman: George L. Cooke, President, The Empire Club of Canada
Head Table Guests
Marnie A. McGarry, Director of Development, Adventure Place, Calico School and a Director, The Empire Club of Canada; Ethan Siller, Grade 11 Student, Northern Secondary School; Rev. Katherine Treganowan, Pastoral Associate, St. Paul's L'Amoreaux Anglican Church; The Hon. David R. Peterson, P.C., Q.C., Partner, Cassels, Brock & Blackwell; John A. Campion, Partner, Fasken Campbell Godfrey and a Past President, The Empire Club of Canada; Madam Justice Rosalie S. Abella, Court of Appeal of Ontario; The Hon. Charles Harnick, Attorney General of Ontario and Minister Responsible for Native Affairs; Nalini Stewart, President, The Canadian Club of Toronto; The Hon. R. Roy McMurtry, Chief Justice of Ontario; Malcolm J. MacKillop, Partner, Borden & Elliot; and Catherine Steele, Vice-President, Toronto and Partner, Gervais, Gagnon, Covington & Associates and a Director, The Empire Club of Canada.
Introduction by George L. Cooke
I wonder how many of us are aware that the 3-M factor in the federal cabinet has nothing to do with scotch tape or "post it notes," but is used by "pundits" to refer to Ministers Martin, Manley and McLellan!
Today, we are particularly honoured to have Minister Anne McLellan with us.
Minister McLellan was first elected to the federal Parliament in 1993--by one vote, and on recount by 11 votes. This distinction garnered her the nickname to insiders and friends of "Landslide Annie"!
Of note, this landslide produced the first federally elected Liberal from Alberta since the days of 'Trudeaumania.' The second more comfortable victory by the Liberals in 1997 marked the first time in my lifetime that a federal Liberal member was re-elected from Alberta.
In addition to being Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada, Minister McLellan sits on all four permanent cabinet committees--the only member of such distinction--and chairs one of them: the social committee.
A student from a one-room school house on the south shore of Nova Scotia, raised on a 200-year-old family farm, Minister McLellan holds a Bachelor of Arts degree and a law degree from Dalhousie University, and a Master of Laws degree from King's College, University of London. She taught law at the University of New Brunswick and at the University of Alberta, and was Acting Dean at the latter, prior to her election to Parliament. In spite of an outstanding legal background--which serves her and Canada well in her current role--Minister McLellan was first appointed to cabinet as Minister of Natural Resources. In this role she is recognised for having worked miracles developing solid working relationships, support and trust for the government within that sector, one of obvious great importance to the province she represents.
We have a truly talented and accomplished Canadian as our guest today. Please join me in welcoming Minister Anne McLellan to this joint meeting of our clubs.
Thank you for that kind introduction. It is a pleasure, indeed an honour, to be here and to have this opportunity to address a joint meeting of the Canadian Club and the Empire Club.
It is also a pleasure to be here in Toronto, a city that is prospering again and helping drive the country's current economic expansion. This city, the province of Ontario, along with Quebec, have long been the engines of economic growth in Canada. As the Member of Parliament for Edmonton West, it gives me great pleasure to note, that while this may still be true, they are being joined by the West and its urban centres, such as Calgary and Vancouver. This is not just good for the West, but for the entire country.
I make these introductory remarks because I have been asked, today, to provide a view from the West: to provide my perspective on issues as a representative of the government and the cabinet from Western Canada, representation that is not quite as abundant as that in Ontario. I will take this opportunity to reflect a little on the country's expanding power base, on the fact that the West is assuming an increasingly important economic role in our federation, and what this means for the governance of our country and our choices. In this respect, I will touch on some of my challenges as Minister of Justice.
Thanks, in part, to the policies of our government, the national economy is doing well after the very difficult years of the late 1980s and early 1990s. The unemployment rate, though still too high, has fallen to its lowest level in seven years and keeps falling. Inflation is low. Consumer and business confidence are reaching record highs. Short- and long-term interest rates are lower in Canada than in the United States. After years of pessimism, Canadians feel optimistic again, both about the national economy and about their own personal prospects.
We have gone from the second-highest deficit-to-GDP ratio of the G-7 nations to the lowest. The OECD forecasts that Canada will lead the G-7 nations in economic and job growth this year and next. We are now in the very fortunate position to start prudently and responsibly identifying our priorities as a country and investing in them--priorities such as education, health care and personal tax reductions. This is where our nation is today. But what's interesting is how we got here.
For the past few years, the West's economy has consistently outpaced that of the rest of the country, seizing the advantages and opportunities, particularly export opportunities, brought about by the country's fiscal turnaround. In 1996, GPP growth in the prairie provinces was twice that of Ontario's and three times that of Quebec's. In 1997, as the recovery consolidated, Ontario's and Quebec's GPP growth approached that of the prairies, but again Alberta led the country with growth of 5.5 per cent. It is also worth noting that, unlike the late 80s where growth occurred primarily in Ontario, this has been a truly national recovery.
The story is the same on the unemployment front. Alberta's unemployment rate today is 5.2 per cent, the lowest in the country. Manitoba's and Saskatchewan's are right behind. British Columbia has been having a tough time given Asian markets, but we cannot forget that for years B.C. was an export champion in our national economy--and will be again.
The West is not just growing, it's diversifying. Manitoba's economy is the most diversified in Canada. In Alberta, while oil and gas is still the major contributor to provincial GPP, the manufacturing and service sectors have steadily increased their combined contribution over the past 10 years. The province today derives much more revenue from non-energy exports than it did in the 1980s. So, while it is obviously a concern when oil prices drop, as they have recently, the provincial economy maintains its strength and vibrancy.
Here are some other indicators of the West's growing strength. Canada West Foundation reports that 46 per cent of Albertans own or have access to home computers versus the Canadian average of 36 per cent. My home of Edmonton, along with Vancouver and Calgary, sell more books per capita than any other Canadian cities. And, if the statisticians have this right, Alberta and B.C. have the highest percentage of citizens with a post-secondary education.
Calgary's population, at 840,000, is small compared to the millions who live in Toronto or Montreal. Yet Calgary hosts the second-largest number of head offices in Canada.
Population also continues to move westward. In the period between 1986 and 1996, B.C.'s population grew around 50,000 a year--the equivalent of moving a city the size of Kingston to the coast each year. A percentage of this growth comes from outside Canada, but most is from within. Born in Nova Scotia, I am an example of this internal migration. And as Newfoundlanders are the first to tell you, their fourth-largest city is Fort McMurray, Alberta.
What we are seeing is, quite frankly, a gradual economic realignment. What I've described speaks to the intellectual vigour and corporate reach that is taking place across this country. It is surely a strength we must all welcome, for it is contributing to our pluralism and diversity as a nation and is providing new opportunities and prosperity for all Canadians.
It is in this context of the West's economic and population growth, diversification and confidence, that the country, or more specifically Central Canada, experiences the West's demands for greater influence in the country's affairs. The Reform Party is one manifestation of this, although I would argue that it is an unfortunate one, for it tends to be one of negativism and division. Most Westerners are not angry or defensive; they are confident, optimistic and tolerant. They deserve a more positive expression of their ideas and our government is working hard to provide the means for that expression. However, we must view these demands as not only natural, but that understanding them and responding to them are essential to Canada's continued growth and prosperity.
The first point I'd make is that the West's influence is already strong. Fiscal responsibility and the belief in a more streamlined, smaller government are ideas that, first championed in Western Canada, are now virtually gospel--embraced by all Canadian governments regardless of political stripe.
The continued deregulation of oil and gas markets, the recognition of the national importance of Alberta's and Saskatchewan's oil sands and our government's focus on Asian markets and the Pacific Rim, are all examples of western priorities that have achieved a high place on the national agenda. The economic significance of the Pacific Rim for Canada's economy, and Western Canada's in particular, cannot be understated.
But the West wants more and as long as trends continue, these demands will increase. The question is how can we make this happen harmoniously, constructively and to the benefit of all Canadians?
Westerners are often viewed as a relatively homogeneous people who are conservative in their values and political preferences. However, the West possesses a highly diverse, multicultural society, reflected in its plethora of social, cultural and political organisations. The very term, "the West," is misleading, for the social, economic, political and even historical differences of the four western provinces are easily more significant than, for example, those of the Maritimes, yet they are more readily lumped together.
For example, the West has produced several populist political movements. However, one need only compare the socialist C.C.F., born in Saskatchewan, to the conservative Social Credit, born in Alberta, to appreciate the West's diversity. What all western movements have shared is an anti-establishment, or certainly an anti-central Canadian establishment bias, and a desire for a greater decentralisation of powers and more representative institutions.
Beyond the regional protest language, the values expressed by these movements and held by Westerners are not that distinct from those held by other Canadians. The West has always been and will continue to be committed to the growth and development of Canada. I consider Albertans to be among Canada's most ardent patriots. As former Alberta Treasurer Jim Dinning has said, "Albertans believe in the principle of equity. Clearly, those who have are going to be asked to pay more than those who have not... I don't believe this (Alberta) government is a believer in cheque book federalism."
Alberta is the home of the pioneer spirit in Canada. It is a spirit that combines the determination to beat the odds and the fortitude to open up new frontiers. It conveys a strong ethic of individualism and suspicion of state power. But it is balanced by another, gentler side. The hardy pioneers who built Alberta knew that surviving the harsh conditions on the frontier meant helping each other out. It meant sharing and making sure that everyone was treated fairly. This aspect of the pioneer spirit still informs Albertans' actions: approximately 40 per cent of Albertans volunteer, a higher percentage than in any other Canadian province.
So while some Albertans might debate other Canadians on how we, as a nation, should care for our citizens (the appropriate role for government), the fundamental values Albertans hold are the same as those in Ontario, Nova Scotia and Quebec: We believe in a country that cares for its people, particularly those most vulnerable. As Jim Gray, a Calgary oil executive stated in his remarks to the Public Policy Forum in April: "Our (Canadian) distinguishing hallmark is the effective balance we have generated between our high standard of social values developed within the context of a successful and resilient economy. We have achieved this admired balance better than most." This is the challenge our country has successfully met for 130 years: building a nation by focusing on those things that bind us. Our future requires that this continue.
As a Westerner, I am sometimes described by some, in the media, as a small-c Liberal justice minister. Some have viewed my priorities--crime prevention, the renewal of our youth justice system and victims' rights--as evidence of my western perspective. But one of the most important things I have learned over the past year in this portfolio is how justice issues transcend provincial and regional boundaries. While Quebeckers show a higher (though by no means very high) degree of support for the Young Offenders Act than in other parts of Canada, where it is easily the most unpopular piece of justice legislation, fear of youth crime is just as high in Quebec as elsewhere. There is no question that fear of crime and questions about the ability of our criminal justice system to deal with it is a growing concern in every part of this country. And we also know that this is happening at a time when crime rates have been going down in most categories for the past five years or more.
These concerns reflect the fact that Canadian society has undergone profound change over the past 30 years. We've evolved, for example, from a relatively homogeneous country bent on assimilating immigrants and Aboriginal people to a pluralistic one, whose commitments to multiculturalism and Aboriginal self-government are enshrined in our Constitution; from a country whose political discourse was dominated by a few privileged voices to one in which the number of viewpoints heard in public debate in any given day defies quantification. And we now have a Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which has changed the perceptions and expectations of citizens about what the justice system and legislators are capable of accomplishing in a given situation.
Our justice system has been slow to respond to these new realities and pressures. Aboriginal peoples still feel disadvantaged and isolated in their dealings with the justice system. Litigation is still the paradigm by which the justice system resolves legal disputes, even though such a model is foreign to many people's instinctive sense of how to resolve disagreements or conflicts, and even though litigation creates an atmosphere that deters many people from seeking recourse to justice at all. A general sense of alienation from our judicial institutions resonates more strongly still when they take on a regional angle: expressed in the demands of Westerners and others for greater control of their judicial institutions.
What these issues point to is the need to change the way our justice system operates. We must work to provide Canadians with a greater sense of ownership of the justice system. Canadians, no matter where they live, will only feel that their justice system is working for them if it is accessible, relevant, and inclusive. This may mean changing our institutions, the power they wield, and that of those who run them. It is a goal that is important not just to Westerners, but to all Canadians.
The need to open up our institutions of justice finds no greater argument than when we look at the issue of victims. One of the most troubling aspects of justice in Canada in recent years has been the failure of the system to recognise and respond to the needs of women, children, seniors and other vulnerable groups who have been victimised by crime or family violence.
Victims' rights are not, as some might allege Western issues, although there is no question that the concerns of victims resonate strongly in Western Canada. In a muchheralded study of Quebec's youth justice system, one of its recommendations was to improve the system's treatment and involvement of victims. Improving the treatment of victims is very much a national issue, though doing so effectively requires action that is locally based.
As our justice system has evolved, we have had to understand that justice must be seen to be done at the local, as well as the global level. The precedence of the "Queen's Peace" over the interests of the individual is a fundamental principle--and I would never suggest otherwise--but its practical effect for individuals victimised by crime has been painful, since their needs and concerns often have been ignored. Justice cannot be an abstract concept, but must be one that has meaning and impact in the hearts and minds of individual Canadians.
Reforming our justice system to respond to Canadians' concerns means finding ways to increase the involvement of victims, of the community and of individual Canadians. The federal government is doing this through several initiatives, including our strategy to renew our youth justice system.
Here in Ontario and elsewhere, community-based youth justice alternatives are being developed. These alternatives, used for non-violent offences, involve new ways of making the young offender atone for his or her crime through restitution, community service or other measures that make it plain to the youth the impact of his or her actions. Through our youth justice renewal strategy we want to expand the use of community-based sentencing for non-violent offences, not just because they are less costly and, in most circumstances, more effective, but because they also empower the community.
This week, our government announced a new direction for justice in Canada, when we unveiled our National Strategy on Community Safety and Crime Prevention. In partnership with the provinces, municipalities, NGOs and local community organisations, the Government of Canada will be providing resources to help communities to fight crime by addressing its root causes. It is a programme that recognises an essential fact: The people who live and work in Canadian communities are the ones who best understand their concerns and needs. The federal government won't run this programme; communities across Canada will. It is a concrete example of citizen engagement on an issue of fundamental importance to Canadians--the safety of their communities.
This $32-million annual investment represents 1 per cent of the federal cost of the criminal justice system in Canada and implements a recommendation of both the former National Crime Prevention Council and a House of Commons committee. The programme will be spearheaded by a national Chair, Toronto's former mayor and long-time community advocate, Barbara Hall. She will be assisted by a steering committee comprised of representatives from across the country, including representatives from the provincial and municipal levels of government, the police, the social services network and others.
This programme acknowledges the fact that communities and regions have different crime concerns. Organised crime is a more pressing issue for Montreal and Winnipeg than it is for Edmonton, while child prostitution is a major concern for Calgary and Vancouver. It is a programme that takes decision making out of Ottawa and empowers communities to respond to crime concerns directly.
Crime prevention, youth justice and victims' rights are three areas where we, in the justice system, have an opportunity to make the system more inclusive, responsive, indeed more relevant to Canadians. In doing so, I also think we can also take steps to address regional concerns, be they from the West or Ontario. Canada is a large country, with a small population spread over great distances. Allowing for greater public ownership of our institutions is a much greater challenge in a country as large as ours, but it also makes the importance of meeting it that much greater.
Canadians from all regions built Canada by working together, overcoming differences of language and culture. It has not always been easy, but the challenge of achieving understanding and respect for Canada's differences is a noble one and our ability to do so is what sets us apart from so many other countries around the world. We can continue to build this country, confident that the values that led us to this point are shared by all Canadians. Westerners may have some needs or feel some frustrations that differ from Ontarians, Atlantic Canadians or Quebeckers, but we have long worked and will continue to work toward common purposes.
Georges-Etienne Cartier--one of the Fathers of Confederation--said that Canada was founded on the "kindred interest and sympathies" of our different communities. As we enter a new era of prosperity, it is my hope and belief that Canadians and their governments will find it easier to overcome our regional differences and work together in partnership. As Prime Minister Jean Chretien said to the Economic Club of New York this March, "Our nation has emerged to a bright future full of hope and promise, with new confidence in its abilities and a new belief in its destiny."
He is right. And Canadians, regardless of where they live, feel that hope, that promise and that confidence. The new millennium will dawn brightly for this great nation and its people.
I thank you for inviting me to be with you today.
The appreciation of the meeting was expressed by Nalini Stewart, President, The Canadian Club of Toronto.